James Pattinson's Top 50 AFL Players

[flight23]

Juggalo, lest we forget

[Mr Snrub]

Thompson-gate

[Big Sledge]

You can neg me till the cows come home, really couldn't give a fuck, it only reinforces the fact you've spat it like a weak bitch.
And I've provided enough justification why he isn't worthy #12 spot, pity a biased, fragile bitch like you can't see that.

Have a nice day.

You've provided no justification at all other than labelling a plodder, naming a bunch of players who didn't have better years than him and Mike's top 50 which left out Swallow, Rockliff along with Thompson.

So TING's list > Mike's

[TakingthePapiss]

Strong sarcasm was not picked up.

[James Pattinson]

At no stage did I mention this list was based on any future potential, if it was, Marc Murphy would be #1 and Mitch Robinson would have be in the top 10.

[TakingthePapiss]

Let's use an extremely Vic-centro media guy as a guide shall we

In all serious, did that faggot include ANYONE that doesn't play for a Victorian club?

[Rumblah]

Guess I should cause a ruckus over Hodge featuring in the top 15 in Mike Sheahan's list.

[Beast]

TING said it's mostly last year and some influence from the years before it...

I'm done arguing, I'm out

When TING asked me where would I have Thompson I said "in the 30's" an hour later you link us with Mike's post 2011 top 50 that has him at #38 and try to use it as some sort of ammunition against me

[Mr Snrub]

When TING asked me where would I have Thompson I said "in the 30's" an hour later you link us with Mike's post 2011 top 50 that has him at #38 and try to use it as some sort of ammunition against me

My apologizes, I did not see you say that, I was thinking you said "Thompson shouldn't be in the top 50"

[Beast]

My apologizes, I did not see you say that, I was thinking you said "Thompson shouldn't be in the top 50"

No worries mate, I was too smashed to point this out last night

[James Pattinson]

#9
Sir Christopher Judd (Carlton Football Club)
DOB: 08/09/1983 (Age: 28)
Position: The greatest midfielder of all time
Drafted: Pick 3, 2001
Debut: Round 2, 2002 vs. Collingwood
Games: 222

The champ. He's achieved everything in the game so far, the only thing left to tick off is a Premiership with Carlton. His 2011 wasn't as good as his 2010, but he still went into the Brownlow count as favourite. He turned himself into the elite inside midfielder in the competition when he joined Carlton, after being the best outside damaging midfielder in the competition at West Coast. He averages a little bit under a goal a game. The only flaw with his game is his over-head marking and set shot kicking. Most fans will make fun of his ball use, but they're just jealous that the greatest midfielder of our generation (possibly ever) is playing for Carlton. He actually improved his overhead marking in 2011, compared to previous seasons, but the end of his 2011 was poor after son Oscar was born. His 2012 will be outstanding again as he's as consistent as anyone who has ever played the game. Despite having a poorer year by his own standards, he still won the AFLPA MVP and the award will soon be named after Judd instead of Leigh Matthews.

1 x Premiership Player (2006)
2 x Brownlow Medallist (2004, 2010)
1 x Norm Smith Medallist (2005)
2 x AFLPA MVP - Leigh Matthews Trophy (2006, 2011)
2 x West Coast Eagles Best & Fairest (2004, 2006)
3 x Carlton Best & Fairest (2008, 2009, 2010)
6 x All Australian (2004, 2006, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011)

[Indie]

Kudos for having Murphy above Judd.

[Axel.]

Kudos for having Murphy above Judd.

Think he got 9 and 1 mixed up..

..

[James Pattinson]

#8
Sir Marc Murphy (Carlton Football Club)
DOB: 19/07/1987 (Age: 24)
Position: Gun midfielder
Drafted: Pick 1, 2005
Debut: Round 1, 2006 vs. Melbourne
Games: 126

The heir apparent at Carlton. Murphy was outstanding in 2011. He just went from strength to strength. He failed to gather 20 possessions only once during the season (against Collingwood in Round 4), he kicked a goal a game, worked on his tackling and he gets his hands on the ball a lot and wins free kicks. He's very quick over the ground and loves to take a bounce when running with the ball - his disposal is generally very good and he's a decent mark for a guy of his size. I can see him getting better and taking the #1 mantle in Carlton's midfield and getting a hard tag before Judd does in the near future. He polled 19 Brownlow votes in 2011 and is my favourite to win it in 2012.

1 x Carlton Best & Fairest (2011)
1 x All Australian (2011)

[Big Sledge]

Sir Christopher Judd (Carlton Football Club)

Position: The greatest midfielder of all time

Most fans will make fun of his ball use, but they're just jealous that the greatest midfielder of our generation (possibly ever) is playing for Carlton.

Gary Ablett Jnr is the greatest midfielder of our generation, by a decent distance as well.